Appeal court upholds recovery of $8 mln from IKEA in favor of Russian businessman
MOSCOW, October 17 (RAPSI) – The Smolensk Regional Court has dismissed an appeal filed by IKEA's Russian division IKEA Mos against a lower court’s ruling ordering the company to pay businessman Konstantin Ponomarev more than 507 million rubles ($8 million) over rented diesel generators, RAPSI reported on Monday.
The court has also upheld seizure of monetary assets belonging to IKEA Mos and prohibition on its reorganization.
Moreover, the court on IKEA Mos lawyers’ complaint has revoked special court rulings on the alleged commitment of crimes against justice by them issued to the address of the Prosecutor General’s Office and Moscow City Bar; but passed a similar rider towards Russia’s Investigative Committee.
In August 2016, the Krasninsky District Court in Smolensk issued a ruling in favor of the businessman in the dispute with IKEA’s division.
The ruling was handed down after Joakim Virtanen, former general manager at IKEA division in St. Petersburg, had admitted to giving false testimony against Ponomarev in the case.
Virtanen said that he lied to investigators and gave false testimony in court at the request of lawyers who acted on behalf of IKEA Mos.
As a result, Alexaner Khokhlov and Semyon Shevchenko who had been hired by IKEA Mos are suspected of pressing witnesses, evidence tampering and procuring perjury. A complaint against the lawyers has been filed with the Prosecutor General’s Office. Moscow City Bar was requested to check the lawyers for breach of Code of Ethics and Professional Conduct.
Ponomarev is embroiled in a long-standing dispute with IKEA that opted to rent diesel generators to power its shopping malls in St. Petersburg. Five criminal cases were opened against the businessman at the request of the Swedish retailer. However, a probe over alleged fraud found nothing, and the cases were dropped.
As a matter of fact, Ponomarev is one of the key witnesses in the case against Hermitage Capital Management CEO William Browder who stands accused of tax evasion on a large scale in Russia. According to investigators, Browder and Sergei Magnitsky, a Russian lawyer and auditor, set up an illegal scheme to siphon off over 500 million rubles (about $7.9 million). Browder was sentenced in July 2013 to nine years in prison in absentia. Magnitsky, who died in prison in suspicious circumstances, was found guilty of tax evasion in a posthumous trial.